top of page

Bill 3-24 How Zoning Affects African American Neighborhoods.

In dissecting the proposed bill establishing the MA1-B Neighborhood Marina zoning district, it's clear that its implications could profoundly influence our neighborhoods. Here's a closer look at its potential effects:

  1. Zoning Regulation Specificity: The bill seeks to introduce precise regulations tailored to the unique needs of neighborhood marinas within the MA1-B district. While this may promise better management of waterfront access and recreational activities, it raises questions about how these regulations might reshape the character of our neighborhoods.

  2. Bulk Regulations: With specific requirements governing the size, scale, and placement of structures in the MA1-B districts, concerns arise about alterations to the neighborhood's aesthetics and ambiance. Controlling factors like building height and setbacks could significantly alter the neighborhood's visual landscape.

  3. Permitted Uses: Anticipated regulations will likely permit activities directly associated with marina operations, such as boat storage, fueling stations, and retail outlets for marine equipment. While supporting marine businesses is essential, we must assess how these activities might impact local commerce diversity.

  4. Conditional and Special Exception Uses: Certain uses may be conditionally permitted or require special exceptions within the MA1-B districts, allowing flexibility while demanding additional scrutiny. It's crucial to ensure that such flexibility doesn't undermine the integrity of our neighborhood or favor specific stakeholders unfairly.

  5. Marina Caretakers Residences: The bill's provisions for marina caretaker residences suggest a potential shift in the neighborhood's residential landscape. While these accommodations may serve a purpose, it's vital to ensure they contribute positively to our community's environment and remain compatible with its overall goals.

Now, let's examine the potential negative impacts of these changes on an African American historical neighborhood:

  1. Gentrification Pressures: Historically marginalized neighborhoods, like ours, face the risk of gentrification with specialized zoning districts such as MA1-B. Increased property values could lead to rising rents and taxes, potentially displacing long-term residents, including African American communities, to less affordable areas.

  2. Cultural Displacement: The influx of marina-related developments might attract a different demographic, posing a risk of cultural displacement within our African American historical neighborhood. This could alter the neighborhood's identity and erode its sense of community.

  3. Limited Access to Resources: The bill's focus on marina-related activities might inadvertently prioritize certain groups over others. African American communities, already facing barriers to resources, could be further marginalized if the bill disproportionately benefits wealthier residents or developers.

  4. Environmental Justice Concerns: Historically marginalized communities, including African American neighborhoods, often bear a disproportionate burden of environmental hazards. The expansion of marina activities within MA1-B could introduce new environmental risks, potentially affecting the health and well-being of African American residents.

  5. Lack of Community Input and Representation: Meaningful participation from African American residents and organizations in the bill's development and implementation processes is crucial. Without adequate representation, zoning regulations may fail to address the unique needs and concerns of our African American historical neighborhood.

In conclusion, while the MA1-B zoning district aims to regulate neighborhood marinas effectively, it's imperative to consider its potential negative impacts on historically marginalized communities like ours. Ensuring equitable development requires robust community engagement, access to resources, and policies that prioritize cultural heritage and social cohesion within our neighborhoods. We must actively advocate for decisions that serve the best interests of our community now and in the future.

33 views0 comments


bottom of page